Players who should've made it into the Hall of Fame
Written by Miles
These players all have very impressive stat lines, and most of them probably would have made it into the Baseball Hall of Fame if they hadn’t done something wrong during their career. Sometimes though, they didn’t even do anything wrong, and it just leaves us scratching our heads trying to figure out why they didn’t make it in. In this article, I go into all of the players that, based on their stats, should’ve gotten their own spot in Cooperstown, hope you enjoy!
Roger Clemens
Roger Clemens…Where to start? Seven-time Cy Young Award winner (which is the most by any one player in MLB history), 11 All-Star selections, 2-Time World Series Champion, 4.6k strikeouts. He was truly one-of-a-kind, and surely made it into the Hall of Fame with ease right? Nope. He was accused of using PED’s to up his game, and was therefore banned from ever making it into the Hall. Makes you wonder what his career would’ve been without the steroids and if he would’ve made his way into Cooperstown anyway. Many people thought he should’ve made it in despite the accusations, but obviously he wasn’t able to persuade everyone.
Barry Bonds
Barry Bonds, the home run machine, this hard-hitting player is the all-time home run leader, with 762 career home runs. In 2001 he made history by hitting 72 home runs in a single season, which nobody has yet to break, and likely won’t for a long time. His other achievements are no less impressive; 14-time All-Star, 7-time NL MVP, 8-time Gold Glove Award winner, you could say he was pretty good. Unfortunately, he fell prey to the steroids accusations as well, leading to his exclusion from the Hall of Fame.
Shoeless Joe Jackson
Shoeless Joe Jackson, in 1911 he set the rookie record (still unbroken) of a .408 batting average. Over his 9-year career (which was cut short, we’ll get to that later), he had an incredible batting average of .356, which is the third highest in MLB history! He also was a World Series Champion in 1917, plus, he holds the Cleveland Guardians and Chicago White Sox franchise records for triples in a season. Everything was going so well for this young and productive star…that was until the Black Sox Scandal in 1919. Basically, he was accused of intentionally throwing the World Series, and for doing this he would get anywhere from $70,00-$100,000 from gamblers as compensation. He was immediately banned from ever playing in the Majors again. He also would never be in the Baseball Hall of Fame due to their rule which states that players banned because of gambling-related misconduct or game-fixing are ineligible for induction, and that rule has kept Jackson out of Cooperstown.
Curt Schilling
Curt Schilling, he really just knew how to win. I’ll let the stats speak for themselves here, 6-time All-Star, 3-time World Series Champion (2001, 2004, and 2007), was the World Series MVP in 2001, NLCS MVP in 1993, 2-time MLB Wins leader, 2-time NL Strikeout leader, and he had a postseason record of 11-2. That, you would assume, should merit a spot in Cooperstown, but it didn’t. The reason for this is a little different than you would think, no he didn’t take steroids, no he didn’t cheat, no he didn’t gamble, the real reason is that he was not very careful with his words. He spoke out against very controversial subjects, leading to the voters being hesitant give him their vote, some writers stated that they found it impossible to reward someone they see as offensive and intolerant. Truly an odd case of a star not being voted in.
Pete Rose
We all knew he was coming, maybe the most deserving on this list, Pete Rose. He was the NL Rookie of the Year in 1963, NL MVP in 1973, World Series MVP in 1975, had 2 Gold Glove Awards, a Silver Slugger Award, a 17-time All-Star (at 5 different positions), 3-time World Series Champion, plus the Cincinnati Reds retired his number 14. His stats are some of the most impressive in baseball history, I’m sure you know why he didn’t make it into the Hall of Fame, but if not, let me enlighten you. In 1989, there was an investigation into Pete Rose and it was discovered that he had gambled on games while he played, including games for his own team that he had control over. This is a big violation of Major League Baseball’s terms and he was banned from playing or ever being eligible for the Hall of Fame. This is still a huge debate in the baseball community about whether his actions were bad enough to justify not allowing him into Cooperstown. Where do you land on the issue?
These guys were all excellent baseball players, but failed to make it to Cooperstown due to their actions outside of baseball. This is why it’s so important to be a role model on and off the field, that is when you are recognized as someone worthy of the highest honor in baseball. Thanks for reading, and make sure to check out our other blog posts if you liked this one!
Join Our Newsletter
Want updates on discounts and info for our 2025 tours? Sign up for our Newsletter today!
Scroll to Top